A Novel Approach to Identifying Mantle‐Equilibrated Zircon by Using Trace Element Chemistry

Abstract

Abstract One of the requirements for inferring mantle redox states via zircon Ce/Ce* oxybarometry and Ti‐in‐zircon thermometry is to select mantle‐equilibrated zircon derived from melts that have not interacted with the hydrosphere nor assimilated exogenous materials. Traditional protocols for identifying mantle‐equilibrated zircon require a comprehensive examination of whole rock geochemistry in addition to zircon morphology, texture, and trace element and isotopic measurements. This study proposes a simple filter scheme for selecting mantle‐equilibrated zircon using trace element systematics alone (P, Ti, Y, Nb, rare earth elements [REE], Hf, Th, and U) to provide the geological context of zircon from three perspectives: (1) mineral inclusions; (2) source melt petrogenesis; and (3) zircon saturation context. The filter scheme presented here, comprising of 13 criteria, is established based on detailed classifications of 2,173 zircon analyses from 30 independent references and is shown to distinguish between nonmagmatic zircon, magmatic zircon with significant inclusions and/or sourced from highly enriched source melts, and mantle‐equilibrated zircon. The filter scheme is validated with known, well‐characterized mantle‐equilibrated Jack Hills zircon (n = 53) and derives an average mantle redox state of ΔFMQ1.5±1.3 (sd) circa 4,400 Ma, in agreement with previously published results. Further application of the filter scheme to zircon dataset (n = 76) from three metasedimentary rocks successfully reveals the mantle‐equilibrated zircon in the dataset, and implies a mantle redox state of ΔFMQ−1.5±1.3 (sd) circa 2,950 Ma. This filter scheme can be applied to studies of out‐of‐context detrital and/or xenocrystic zircon in the future.

Keywords

• Zircon Ce/Ce* oxybarometry
• Ti‐in‐zircon thermometry
• Mantle oxygen fugacity