The development of an eye movement-based deep learning system for laparoscopic surgical skills assessment

Abstract

Abstract The development of valid, reliable, and objective methods of skills assessment is central to modern surgical training. Numerous rating scales have been developed and validated for quantifying surgical performance. However, many of these scoring systems are potentially flawed in their design in terms of reliability. Eye-tracking techniques, which provide a more objective investigation of the visual-cognitive aspects of the decision-making process, recently have been utilized in surgery domains for skill assessment and training, and their use has been focused on investigating differences between expert and novice surgeons to understand task performance, identify experienced surgeons, and establish training approaches. Ten graduate students at the National Taiwan University of Science and Technology with no prior laparoscopic surgical skills were recruited to perform the FLS peg transfer task. Then k-means clustering algorithm was used to split 500 trials into three dissimilar clusters, grouped as novice, intermediate, and expert levels, by an objective performance assessment parameter incorporating task duration with error score. Two types of data sets, namely, time series data extracted from coordinates of eye fixation and image data from videos, were used to implement and test our proposed skill level detection system with ensemble learning and a CNN algorithm. Results indicated that ensemble learning and the CNN were able to correctly classify skill levels with accuracies of 76.0% and 81.2%, respectively. Furthermore, the incorporation of coordinates of eye fixation and image data allowed the discrimination of skill levels with a classification accuracy of 82.5%. We examined more levels of training experience and further integrated an eye tracking technique and deep learning algorithms to develop a tool for objective assessment of laparoscopic surgical skill. With a relatively unbalanced sample, our results have demonstrated that the approach combining the features of visual fixation coordinates and images achieved a very promising level of performance for classifying skill levels of trainees.