Conservation Letters (May 2023)
Economics of conservation law enforcement by rangers across Asia
- Mohammad S. Farhadinia,
- Paul J. Johnson,
- Vignesh Kamath,
- Ehab Eid,
- Hadi Al Hikmani,
- Hüseyin Ambarlı,
- Zahangir Alom,
- Elshad Askerov,
- Polawee Buchakiet,
- Bayarbaatar Buuveibaatar,
- Alexander Gavashelishvili,
- Khatuna Tsiklauri,
- Mariya A. Gritsina,
- Iding Haidir,
- Saw Htun,
- Muhammad Kabir,
- Gopal Khanal,
- Andrew Kittle,
- Maxim A. Koshkin,
- Rahim Kulenbekov,
- Zairbek Kubanychbekov,
- Antony Lynam,
- Aishwarya Maheshwari,
- Ugyen Penjor,
- Akchousanh Rasphone,
- Hana Raza,
- Tim Redford,
- Afag Rizayeva,
- Tatjana Rosen,
- Pavel Weinberg,
- Anna Yachmennikova,
- Nobuyuki Yamaguchi,
- David W. Macdonald
Affiliations
- Mohammad S. Farhadinia
- Department of Biology and Oxford Martin SchoolUniversity of Oxford OxfordUK
- Paul J. Johnson
- Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, Department of BiologyUniversity of Oxford OxfordUK
- Vignesh Kamath
- UN Environment Programme World Conservation Monitoring Centre (UNEP‐WCMC) CambridgeUK
- Ehab Eid
- IUCN SSC Steering Committee Members AmmanJordan
- Hadi Al Hikmani
- Office for Conservation of the EnvironmentDiwan of Royal Court MuscatOman
- Hüseyin Ambarlı
- Department of Wildlife Ecology and Management, Faculty of ForestryDuzce University DuzceTurkey
- Zahangir Alom
- Wildlife Conservation Society DhakaBangladesh
- Elshad Askerov
- The Institute of Zoology of Azerbaijan NAS BakuAzerbaijan
- Polawee Buchakiet
- Umphang Wildlife Sanctuary Nong LuangThailand
- Bayarbaatar Buuveibaatar
- Mongolia ProgramWildlife Conservation Society UlaanbaatarMongolia
- Alexander Gavashelishvili
- Center of Biodiversity Studies, Institute of EcologyIlia State University TbilisiGeorgia
- Khatuna Tsiklauri
- National Environment Agency of GeorgiaMinistry of Environment and Agriculture of Georgia PotiGeorgia
- Mariya A. Gritsina
- Institute of ZoologyAcademy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan TashkentUzbekistan
- Iding Haidir
- Directorate of Planning and Information of Conservation AreasMinistry of Environment and Forestry Central JakartaIndonesia
- Saw Htun
- Myanmar Biodiversity Fund YangonMyanmar
- Muhammad Kabir
- Wildlife Ecology Lab, Department of Forestry & Wildlife ManagementUniversity of Haripur HaripurPakistan
- Gopal Khanal
- Department of National Parks and Wildlife Conservation, Ministry of Forests and EnvironmentGovernment of Nepal, Singha Durbar KathmanduNepal
- Andrew Kittle
- The Wilderness & Wildlife Conservation Trust Sri Lanka
- Maxim A. Koshkin
- Ilbirs Foundation BishkekKyrgyzstan
- Rahim Kulenbekov
- Ilbirs Foundation BishkekKyrgyzstan
- Zairbek Kubanychbekov
- Ilbirs Foundation BishkekKyrgyzstan
- Antony Lynam
- Wildlife Conservation SocietyCenter for Global Conservation New YorkNew YorkUSA
- Aishwarya Maheshwari
- Vasundhara Sector 5 Uttar PradeshGhaziabadIndia
- Ugyen Penjor
- Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, Department of BiologyUniversity of Oxford OxfordUK
- Akchousanh Rasphone
- Wildlife Conservation SocietyLao PDR Program, Lao PDR VientianeLao Peoples Democratic Repblc
- Hana Raza
- Leopards Beyond BordersSulaimani‐Kurdistan Region Iraq
- Tim Redford
- Freeland Foundation BangkokThailand
- Afag Rizayeva
- SILVIS Lab, Department of Forest and Wildlife EcologyUniversity of Wisconsin‐Madison WisconsinMadisonUSA
- Tatjana Rosen
- Caucasus Nature Fund TbilisiGeorgia
- Pavel Weinberg
- North‐Ossetian State Nature Reserve RSO‐AlaniaAlagirRussia
- Anna Yachmennikova
- A.N. Severtsov Institute of Ecology and EvolutionRussian Academy of Sciences MoscowRussia
- Nobuyuki Yamaguchi
- Institute of Tropical Biodiversity and Sustainable DevelopmentUniversiti Malaysia Terengganu Kuala TerengganuMalaysia
- David W. Macdonald
- Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, Department of BiologyUniversity of Oxford OxfordUK
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12943
- Journal volume & issue
-
Vol. 16,
no. 3
pp. n/a – n/a
Abstract
Abstract Biodiversity targets, under the Kunming‐Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, prioritize both conservation area and their effectiveness. The effective management of protected areas (PAs) depends greatly on law enforcement resources, which is often tasked to rangers. We addressed economic aspects of law enforcement by rangers working in terrestrial landscapes across Asia. Accordingly, we used ranger numbers and payment rates to derive continental‐scale estimates. Ranger density has decreased by 2.4‐fold since the 1990s, increasing the median from 10.9 to 26.4 km2 of PAs per ranger. Rangers were generally paid more than the minimum wage (median ratio = 1.9) and the typical salaries in agriculture, forestry, and fishing sector (median ratio = 1.2). Annual spending on ranger salaries varied widely among countries, with a median of annual US71 km−2 of PA. Nearly 208,000 rangers patrolling Asian PAs provide an invaluable opportunity to develop ranger‐based monitoring plans for evaluating the conservation performance. As decision‐makers frequently seek an optimum number of law enforcement staff, our study provides a continental baseline median of 46.3 km2 PA per ranger. Our findings also provide a baseline for countries to improve their ranger‐based law enforcement which is critical for their Kunming‐Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework targets.
Keywords