A comparative study between low- and high-tech methods for the detection and mitigation of illicit connections in stormwater systems

Abstract

Illicit connections of wastewater to stormwater systems are the main drawback of separate sewer systems, as they lead to a direct discharge of untreated wastewater to the aquatic environment. Consequently, several inspection methods have been developed for detecting illicit connections. This study simultaneously applied several low- and high-tech methods for the detection of illicit connections in the same catchment (De Heuvel, the Netherlands). The methods included mesh wire screens for capturing coarse contamination, measurements of electroconductivity and temperature, sampling and quantification of Escherichia coli and extended-spectrum ß-lactamase-producing E. coli (ESBL-EC), DNA analysis via quantitative polymerase chain reaction for human-, dog-, and bird-specific fecal indicators, and distributed temperature sensing. Significant illicit connections could be identified using all methods. Nonetheless, hydraulic conditions and, predominantly, the sewage volume determine whether a misconnection can be detected by especially the low-tech methods. Using these results, the identified misconnections were repaired and biological and DNA analyses were repeated. Our results demonstrate that there were no changes in E. coli or ESBL-EC before and after mitigation, suggesting that these common markers of fecal contamination are not specific enough to evaluate the performance of mitigation efforts. However, a marked decrease in human wastewater markers (HF183) was observed. HIGHLIGHTS Wire screens and conductivity are not suited to detect illicit connections at outlets of storm sewers with large water volumes upstream.; Distributed temperature sensing (DTS) is capable of identifying all sorts of misconnections like household appliances.; HF183 Bacteroides are very effective in determining the presence of human fecal material in storm sewers.; Repeated sampling and quantitative polymerase chain reaction testing could be a prescreening method before labor-intensive DTS.;

Keywords

• bacteroides
• conductivity
• dts
• e. coli
• esbl-ec
• illicit connections