Assessing the Alteration of Soil Quality under Long-Term Fertilization Management in Farmland Soil: Integrating a Minimum Data Set and Developing New Biological Indicators

Abstract

The key role of soil quality improvement in achieving sustainable agricultural development based on highly intensive use of farmland is increasingly being recognized, as is the ponderance of suitable evaluation of the soil quality. The overarching goal of this study was to determine an accurate assessment framework by the comparison of the scoring function (linear and non-linear) and integration method (area and weighted additive), which integrally evaluates the soil quality of an eleven-year field fertilization experiment (including CK, no fertilizer; CF, conventional fertilization; SF, formulated fertilization; SFO, SF with organic fertilizer). Thirty-three properties, including eighteen physiochemical-related and fifteen biological-related properties, associated with soil functions were measured as potential soil quality indicators, and the soil multifunctionality (SMF) was applied to validate the soil quality indices (SQIs). Principal component analysis and relationship analysis were used with indicators sensitive to management to determine a minimum data set (MDS). The results showed that the electrical conductivity, large macroaggregate-associated total nitrogen, small macroaggregate-associated organic carbon, carbon fixation, and enzyme activities of phenol oxidase and cellulase were chosen as the MDS. All the SQIs were significantly correlated with the SMF (p p < 0.05), and the treatment of the organic fertilizer had the highest SQI value (0.66). Soil quality evaluation in long-term fertilized farmland suggested that the soil quality constraints between treatments of synthetic and organic fertilizer are related to the soil functions of nutrient cycling and sustain biological activity due to their higher contribution rates to the SQI in the organic fertilizer treatment, which provides insights into ways to reduce the gap in soil quality. The framework method can provide an accurate quantitative tool for the evaluation of soil quality from the target indicators by bridging management objectives and field-level actions.

Keywords

• soil quality index
• organic and inorganic fertilizers
• method comparison
• minimum data set