Frontiers in Microbiology (Feb 2024)

A comparative study of MassARRAY and GeneXpert assay in detecting rifampicin resistance in tuberculosis patients’ clinical specimens

  • Ruixia Liang,
  • Jiankang Li,
  • Yue Zhao,
  • Haoran Qi,
  • Shengjuan Bao,
  • Fen Wang,
  • Hongfei Duan,
  • Hairong Huang

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2024.1287806
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 15

Abstract

Read online

ObjectivesMatrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) has emerged as a potent tool for detecting drug resistance in tuberculosis (TB); however, concerns about its reliability have been raised. In this study, we assessed the reliability of MassARRAY (Sequenom, Inc.), which is a MALDI-TOF MS-based method, by comparing it to the well-established GeneXpert assay (Cepheid) as a reference method.MethodsA retrospective study was conducted using laboratory data retrieved from Henan Chest Hospital (Zhengzhou, China). To ensure a rigorous evaluation, we adopted a comprehensive assessment approach by integrating multiple outcomes of the Xpert assay across various specimen types.ResultsAmong the 170 enrolled TB cases, MassARRAY demonstrated significantly higher sensitivity (85.88%, 146 of 170) compared to the Xpert assay (76.62%, 118 of 154) in TB diagnosis (p < 0.05). The concordance in detecting rifampicin resistance between MassARRAY and the combined outcomes of the Xpert assay was 90%, while it was 97.37% (37 of 38) among smear-positive cases and 89.06% (57 of 64) among culture-positive cases. When compared to the phenotypic susceptibility outcomes of the 12 included drugs, consistency rates of 81.8 to 93.9% were obtained, with 87.9% for multiple drug resistance (MDR) identification.ConclusionMassARRAY demonstrates high reliability in detecting rifampicin resistance, and these findings may offer a reasonable basis for extrapolation to other drugs included in the test panel.

Keywords