Abstract Substituted imidazolium ionic liquids (ILs) were investigated for their reactivity towards Na12Ge17 as a model system containing redox‐sensitive Zintl cluster anions. The ILs proved widely inert for imidazolium cations with a 1,2,3‐trisubstitution at least by alkyl groups, and for the anion bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)azanide (TFSI). A minute conversion of Na12Ge17 observed on long‐time contact with such ILs was not caused by dissolution of the salt‐like compound, and did thus not provide dissolved Ge clusters. Rather, a cation exchange led to the transfer of Na+ ions into solution. In contrast, by using benzophenone as an oxidizer, heterogeneous redox reactions of Na12Ge17 were initiated, transferring a considerable part of Na+ into solution. At optimized conditions, an X‐ray amorphous product NaGe6.25 was obtained, which was thermally convertible to the crystalline type‐II clathrate Na24–δGe136 with almost completely Na‐filled polyhedral cages, and α‐Ge. The presented method thus provides unexpected access to Na24–δGe136 in bulk quantities.