Background: Haemochromatosis (HCH), a common genetic disorder with variable penetrance, results in progressive but understudied iron overload. We prospectively evaluated organ iron loading and cardiac function in a tertiary center HCH cohort. Methods: 42 HCH patients (47 ± 14 years) and 36 controls underwent laboratory workup and cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR), including T1 and T2* mapping. Results: Myocardial T2* (myoT2*), myocardial T1 (myoT1) and liver T2* (livT2*) were lower in patients compared to controls (33 ± 4 ms vs. 36 ± 3 ms [p = 0.004], 964 ± 33 ms vs. 979 ± 25 ms [p = 0.028] and 21 ± 10 ms vs. 30 ± 5 ms [p p = 0.028] and rs = −0.602 [p p < 0.001). Conclusions: In contemporary hemochromatosis, significant myocardial iron overload is rare. Low myocardial T2* and/or T1 values may warrant closer follow-up for accelerated myocardial iron overload even in patients without overt liver overload. Cardiac T2* mapping sequence allows for liver screening at the time of CMR.