Causality between sovereign, quasi-sovereign credit risks and global volatility: The case of Russia

Abstract

The article examines causalities between sovereign, most important quasi-sovereign CDS prices (Gazprom, VTB, Sberbank) for Russia and the global volatility factor embedded in the VIX index dynamics. The analysis refers to the post-bailout period in this major emerging economy (May 2009–July 2013). The causalities are assessed in the time (the Hong test) and frequency (the Breitung–Candelon test) domains. The VIX index dynamics has a strong impact on all Russian CDS, but also receives a non-negligible feedback from them. The sovereign and quasi-sovereign CDS prices exhibit a strong causal connectedness in both domains, with the impact of the quasi-sovereigns (in particular, that of banks) getting more pronounced in the longer run, i.e. over longer time horizons and at lower frequencies. High foreign exposure of the quasi-sovereigns, explicit/implicit public guarantees and the holdings of the Russian sovereign debt on their balances underlie the causalities. Given the systemic role that the government-controlled entities play in the Russian economy, this may lead to the “too big to save” effect with negative implications for financial and fiscal stability.

Keywords

• credit default swaps (CDS)
• causality-in-mean
• causality-in-variance
• bailouts
• the Breitung–Candelon test
• “too big to save” effect
• VIX index