Risk Management and Healthcare Policy (Apr 2021)
Study to Alter the Nuisance Effect of Non-Response Using Scrambled Mechanism
Abstract
Chandraketu Singh,1 Mustafa Kamal,2 Garib Nath Singh,1 Jong-Min Kim3 1Department of Mathematics & Computing, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad, 826004, India; 2Department of Basic Sciences, College of Science and Theoretical Studies, Saudi Electronic University, Dammam, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia; 3Statistics Discipline, Division of Sciences and Mathematics, University of Minnesota-Morris, Morris, MN, 56267-2134, USACorrespondence: Chandraketu SinghDepartment of Mathematics & Computing, Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad, 826004, IndiaEmail [email protected]: In biometric sample surveys, our objective is to get ready-made information for future planning and policy implementations related to the subject matters of highly sensitive issues. In such situations, we apply randomized response/scrambled response techniques. There are many highly sensitive issues which need to be examined over time as they may have a tendency to change. To get rid of these types of practical cases we need a scrambled response technique on successive occasions.Methods: Using an additive and multiplicative technique, we proposed new effective scrambled response models to estimate the population mean of quantitative sensitive characteristics. Degree of privacy protection and unified measure approaches are used to examine the efficacy of the proposed models. Efficiency of the proposed models has been checked using MATLAB software. The utility of the proposed models under two occasions of successive sampling has been also explored using exponential-type estimators. Empirical and simulation studies are carried out to justify the proposition of the proposed estimators using MATLAB software.Results: The percent relative efficiencies of the proposed models are always greater than 100 with respect to the well-known Bar-Lev et al model. In terms of degree of privacy protection, most of the values are greater than 0.5 and closer to 1. Similarly, the values of the proposed models are smaller with respect to the Bar-Lev et al model in terms of a unified measure approach. When the proposed scrambled response models are used on successive occasions, the percent relative efficiency is always found greater than 100 for all cases over its competitors.Discussion: In this study, after deeply examining the properties of the proposed models, we found that the proposed models performed better over the well-known existing model. The proposed models may be used in human survey when we deal with highly sensitive issues. The proposed models also performed better when we utilized them in successive sampling. Hence, if sensitive characteristics change with time, the proposed estimators may be the best alternative to deal with these types of situations.Mathematics Subject Classification: 62D05.Keywords: scrambled response model, privacy protection, successive sampling, mean square error, Monte Carlo simulation
