Frontiers in Psychology (Jan 2020)

Belief Bias Effect in Older Adults: Roles of Working Memory and Need for Cognition

  • Daoqun Ding,
  • Daoqun Ding,
  • Yang Chen,
  • Yang Chen,
  • Ji Lai,
  • Ji Lai,
  • Xiyou Chen,
  • Meng Han,
  • Meng Han,
  • Xiangyi Zhang,
  • Xiangyi Zhang

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02940
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 10

Abstract

Read online

Belief bias is the tendency in syllogistic reasoning to rely on prior beliefs rather than to fully obey logical principles. Few studies have investigated the age effect on belief bias. Although several studies have recently begun to explore this topic, little is known about the psychological mechanisms underlying such an effect. Accordingly, we investigated belief bias in older and young adults and explored the roles of working memory (WM) and need for cognition (NFC) in the relationship between age and reasoning performance. We found that older adults showed a lower accuracy rate compared with young adults when conclusion believability and logical validity were incongruent. However, older adults showed a higher accuracy rate compared with young adults when conclusion believability and logical validity were congruent. The results indicated that in comparison with young adults, prior beliefs hampered logical reasoning more significantly in older adults under incongruent conditions and boosted logical reasoning more significantly under congruent conditions. Moreover, the logic index in older adults was significantly lower than in young adults, and the interaction index of believability and validity in older adults was significantly below zero. Furthermore, NFC mediated the age effect on reasoning performance under the two conditions. By contrast, WM mediated the age effect on reasoning performance only under incongruent conditions and did not act as a mediator under congruent conditions.

Keywords