LoRaWAN Gateway Placement in Smart Agriculture: An Analysis of Clustering Algorithms and Performance Metrics

Abstract

The use of Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) in smart agriculture has emerged in recent years. LoRaWAN (Long Range Wide Area Networks) is widely recognized as one of the most suitable technologies for this application, due to its capacity to transmit data over long distances while consuming little energy. Determining the number and location of gateways (GWs) in a production setting is one of the most challenging tasks of planning and building this type of network. Various solutions to the LoRaWAN gateway placement problem have been proposed in the literature, utilizing clustering algorithms; however, few works have compared the performance of various strategies. Considering all these facts, this paper proposes a strategy for planning the number and localization of LoRaWAN GWs, to cover a vast agricultural region. Four clustering algorithms were used to deploy the network GWs: K-Means and its three versions: Minibatch K-Means; Bisecting K-Means; and Fuzzy c-Means (FCM). As performance metrics, uplink delivery rate (ULDR) and energy consumption were used, to provide subsidies for the network designer and the client, with which to choose the best setup. A stochastic energy model was used to evaluate power consumption. Simulations were performed, considering two scenarios: Scenario 1 with lower-medium concurrence, and Scenario 2 with higher-medium concurrence. The simulations showed that the use of more than two GWs in Scenario 1 did not lead to significant improvements in ULDR and energy consumption, whereas, in Scenario 2, the suggested number of GWs was between 11 and 15. The results showed that for Scenario 1, the FCM algorithm was superior to all alternatives, regarding the ULDR and mean energy consumption, while the K-Means algorithm was superior with respect to maximum energy consumption. In relation to Scenario 2, K-Means caused the best ULDR and mean consumption, while FCM produced the lowest maximum consumption.

Keywords

• Internet of Things
• wireless sensor networks
• agriculture
• clustering
• gateways
• Long Range Wide Area Networks