Assessment of Surface Sterilisation Approaches for the Removal of Pollen DNA from <i>Philaenus spumarius</i>

Abstract

Dietary analysis of herbivorous insects relies on successfully eliminating surface contamination. If this cannot be performed reliably, then it will not be possible to differentiate between plants that the insect is feeding on and plants the insect has been in contact with, either directly or via pollen. Methods in the literature often use bleach and alcohol washes to remove contamination. We perform a controlled metabarcoding baseline study on a herbivorous, xylem-feeding insect, the Meadow Spittlebug (Philaenus spumarius), using Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) sequencing, and identify possible contamination that persists after washes. Despite the reported success of methods in the literature, we find that contamination is still present, leading to possible false-positive results. We hypothesise that pollen is the main source of contamination, its robust nature making it difficult to remove, and conduct a further three experiments with the goal of removing pollen from the surface of Philaenus spumarius. This study investigates the effectiveness of robust bleach/Tween/alcohol washes, sterile gut excision (including combined with Distel application), and ultraviolet light as alternative sterilisation approaches. Overall, our findings indicate that we are unable to remove surface contamination and still detect signals that may originate in the gut. In no experiment did we unequivocally detect plant DNA that originated in the P. spumarius gut.

Keywords

• surface sterilisation
• insect gut content
• plant DNA metabarcoding
• pollen
• meadow spittlebug
• Aphrophoridae