Judgment and Decision Making (Jan 2014)

Foreground-background salience effect in traffic risk communication

  • Tian-Yi Hu,
  • Xin-Wen Jiang,
  • Xiaofei Xie,
  • Xiao-Qin Ma,
  • Chao Xu

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 9, no. 1
pp. 83 – 89

Abstract

Read online

Pie charts are often used to communicate risk, such as the risk of driving. In the foreground-background salience effect (FBSE), foreground (probability of bad event) has greater salience than background (no bad event) in such a chart. Experiment 1 confirmed that the displays format of pie charts showed a typical FBSE. Experiment 2 showed that the FBSE resulted from a difference in cognitive efforts in processing the messages and that a foreground-emphasizing display was easier to process. Experiment 3 manipulated subjects' information processing mindset and explored the interaction between displays format and information processing mindset. In the default mindset, careless subjects displayed a typical FBSE, while those who were instructed to be careful reported similar risk-avoidant behavior preference reading both charts. Suggestions for improving risk communication are discussed. % abstract rewritten

Keywords