Santander Art & Culture Law Review (Dec 2023)

Trade and Export of Archaeological Cultural Goods: A Conflict of Ideas

  • Kamil Zeidler,
  • Paula Chmielowska

DOI
https://doi.org/10.4467/2450050XSNR.23.034.18654
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 2023, no. 2
pp. 333 – 348

Abstract

Read online

Under Polish law objects that are archaeological cultural heritage discovered, accidentally found, or acquired as a result of archaeological research, are the property of the state. This is the situation of the original acquisition of the monument. As a further consequence, archaeological monuments are excluded from trade (becoming res extra commercium). Besides trade, the export of archaeological cultural goods is also highly problematic. In the case of permanent export of a monument abroad, the law imposes the obligation to obtain a permit for such permanent export, issued by the minister responsible for culture and the protection of national heritage. The regulation in Polish law makes it almost impossible for any archaeological cultural goods to be legally exported. The restricted freedom on the market of works of art and monuments in relation to archaeological finds, together with the limited options of mainly temporary export, have created high activity in the black market, calling for a change of approach of the national law towards archaeological heritage. This leads to the question: Should we introduce some legal changes in the ownership rights of archaeological heritage to bring it closer to people?