The Lancet Global Health (Mar 2020)

Cooking fuels and risk of all-cause and cardiopulmonary mortality in urban China: a prospective cohort study

  • Kuai Yu, PhD,
  • Jun Lv, PhD,
  • Gaokun Qiu, PhD,
  • Canqing Yu, PhD,
  • Yu Guo, MSc,
  • Zheng Bian, MSc,
  • Ling Yang, PhD,
  • Yiping Chen, DPhil,
  • Chaolong Wang, ProfPhD,
  • An Pan, ProfPhD,
  • Liming Liang, ProfPhD,
  • Frank B Hu, ProfPhD,
  • Zhengming Chen, ProfDPhil,
  • Liming Li, ProfMPH,
  • Tangchun Wu, ProfPhD,
  • Junshi Chen,
  • Zhengming Chen,
  • Robert Clarke,
  • Rory Collins,
  • Yu Guo,
  • Liming Li,
  • Jun Lv,
  • Richard Peto,
  • Robin Walters,
  • Daniel Avery,
  • Ruth Boxall,
  • Yumei Chang,
  • Yiping Chen,
  • Zhengming Chen,
  • Robert Clarke,
  • Huaidong Du,
  • Simon Gilbert,
  • Alex Hacker,
  • Mike Hill,
  • Michael Holmes,
  • Andri Iona,
  • Christiana Kartsonaki,
  • Rene Kerosi,
  • Ling Kong,
  • Om Kurmi,
  • Garry Lancaster,
  • Sarah Lewington,
  • Kuang Lin,
  • John McDonnell,
  • Iona Millwood,
  • Qunhua Nie,
  • Jayakrishnan Radhakrishnan,
  • Paul Ryder,
  • Sam Sansome,
  • Dan Schmidt,
  • Paul Sherliker,
  • Rajani Sohoni,
  • Becky Stevens,
  • Iain Turnbull,
  • Robin Walters,
  • Jenny Wang,
  • Lin Wang,
  • Neil Wright,
  • Ling Yang,
  • Xiaoming Yang,
  • Zheng Bian,
  • Yu Guo,
  • Xiao Han,
  • Can Hou,
  • Jun Lv,
  • Pei Pei,
  • Chao Liu,
  • Yunlong Tan,
  • Canqing Yu,
  • Zengchang Pang,
  • Ruqin Gao,
  • Shanpeng Li,
  • Shaojie Wang,
  • Yongmei Liu,
  • Ranran Du,
  • Yajing Zang,
  • Liang Cheng,
  • Xiaocao Tian,
  • Hua Zhang,
  • Yaoming Zhai,
  • Feng Ning,
  • Xiaohui Sun,
  • Feifei Li,
  • Silu Lv,
  • Junzheng Wang,
  • Wei Hou,
  • Mingyuan Zeng,
  • Ge Jiang,
  • Xue Zhou,
  • Liqiu Yang,
  • Hui He,
  • Bo Yu,
  • Yanjie Li,
  • Qinai Xu,
  • Quan Kang,
  • Ziyan Guo,
  • Dan Wang,
  • Ximin Hu,
  • Hongmei Wang,
  • Jinyan Chen,
  • Yan Fu,
  • Zhenwang Fu,
  • Xiaohuan Wang,
  • Min Weng,
  • Zhendong Guo,
  • Shukuan Wu,
  • Yilei Li,
  • Huimei Li,
  • Zhifang Fu,
  • Ming Wu,
  • Yonglin Zhou,
  • Jinyi Zhou,
  • Ran Tao,
  • Jie Yang,
  • Jian Su,
  • Fang Liu,
  • Jun Zhang,
  • Yihe Hu,
  • Yan Lu,
  • Liangcai Ma,
  • Aiyu Tang,
  • Shuo Zhang,
  • Jianrong Jin,
  • Jingchao Liu,
  • Zhenzhu Tang,
  • Naying Chen,
  • Ying Huang,
  • Mingqiang Li,
  • Jinhuai Meng,
  • Rong Pan,
  • Qilian Jiang,
  • Jian Lan,
  • Yun Liu,
  • Liuping Wei,
  • Liyuan Zhou,
  • Ningyu Chen,
  • Ping Wang,
  • Fanwen Meng,
  • Yulu Qin,
  • Sisi Wang,
  • Xianping Wu,
  • Ningmei Zhang,
  • Xiaofang Chen,
  • Weiwei Zhou,
  • Guojin Luo,
  • Jianguo Li,
  • Xiaofang Chen,
  • Xunfu Zhong,
  • Jiaqiu Liu,
  • Qiang Sun,
  • Pengfei Ge,
  • Xiaolan Ren,
  • Caixia Dong,
  • Hui Zhang,
  • Enke Mao,
  • Xiaoping Wang,
  • Tao Wang,
  • Xi Zhang,
  • Ding Zhang,
  • Gang Zhou,
  • Shixian Feng,
  • Liang Chang,
  • Lei Fan,
  • Yulian Gao,
  • Tianyou He,
  • Huarong Sun,
  • Pan He,
  • Chen Hu,
  • Xukui Zhang,
  • Huifang Wu,
  • Pan He,
  • Min Yu,
  • Ruying Hu,
  • Hao Wang,
  • Yijian Qian,
  • Chunmei Wang,
  • Kaixu Xie,
  • Lingli Chen,
  • Yidan Zhang,
  • Dongxia Pan,
  • Qijun Gu,
  • Yuelong Huang,
  • Biyun Chen,
  • Li Yin,
  • Huilin Liu,
  • Zhongxi Fu,
  • Qiaohua Xu,
  • Xin Xu,
  • Hao Zhang,
  • Huajun Long,
  • Xianzhi Li,
  • Libo Zhang,
  • Zhe Qiu

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 8, no. 3
pp. e430 – e439

Abstract

Read online

Summary: Background: Cooking practice has transitioned from use of solid fuels to use of clean fuels, with addition of better ventilation facilities. However, the change in mortality risk associated with such a transition remains unclear. Methods: The China Kadoorie Biobank (CKB) Study enrolled participants (aged 30–79 years) from ten areas across China; we chose to study participants from five urban areas where transition from use of solid fuels to clean fuels for cooking was prevalent. Participants who reported regular cooking (weekly or more frequently) at baseline were categorised as persistent clean fuel users, previous solid fuel users, or persistent solid fuel users, according to self-reported fuel use histories. All-cause and cardiopulmonary mortality were identified through linkage to China's Disease Surveillance Point system and local mortality records. Findings: Between June 24, 2004, and July 15, 2008, 226 186 participants living in five urban areas of China were enrolled in the CKB Study. Among 171 677 participants who reported cooking regularly (weekly or more frequently), 75 785 (44%) were persistent clean fuel users, 80 511 (47%) were previous solid fuel users, and 15 381 (9%) were persistent solid fuel users. During a mean of 9·8 (SD 1·7) years of follow-up, 10 831 deaths were documented, including 3819 cardiovascular deaths and 761 respiratory deaths. Compared with persistent clean fuel users, persistent solid fuel users had significantly higher risks of all-cause mortality (hazard ratio [HR] 1·19, 95% CI 1·10–1·28), cardiovascular mortality (1·24, 1·10–1·39), and respiratory mortality (1·43, 1·10–1·85). The excess risk of all-cause and cardiopulmonary mortality fell by more than 60% in 5 years after cessation of solid fuel use and continued to decrease afterwards. Use of ventilation was associated with lower all-cause mortality risk, even among persistent clean fuel users (HR 0·78, 0·69–0·89). Interpretation: Solid fuel use for cooking is associated with a higher risk of mortality, and cessation of solid fuel use cuts excess mortality risks swiftly and substantially within 5 years. Ventilation use also lowers the risk of mortality, even among people who persistently use clean fuels. It is of prime importance for both policy makers and the public to accelerate the transition from solid fuels to clean fuels and promote efficient ventilation to minimise further adverse health effects. Funding: National Natural Science Foundation of China, Wellcome Trust, and Kadoorie Charitable Foundation.