Audiological results of myringoplasty performed by trainee surgeons (ENT residents) under supervision—analytic study

Abstract

Abstract Background Myringoplasty is one of the most common surgeries performed in otology centers, with many factors influencing the success rate, including the size and site of perforation, function of the Eustachian tube, revision surgery, and expertise of the surgeons. It is well established that the perforation closure rate is lower when performed by trainee surgeons than by senior otologists. Myringoplasty performed by trainees tends to pose more iatrogenic trauma to middle ear mucosa, less gentle manipulation of ossicles, and prolonged operation time compared with operations performed by experienced surgeons, all of which might produce more damage to middle ear structures and consequently negatively affect the closure rate of TM and audiological outcome. This study aimed to assess the audiological outcomes of successfully closed perforation myringoplasty performed by a trainee under supervision. Methods The study design was an analytic cross-sectional study of 35 patients aged between 6 and 62 years diagnosed with safe TM perforation. All patients had two audiograms, one before surgery and the other 3 months after surgery. The exclusion criteria included any case with cholesteatoma, tumor, tympanosclerosis, or ossicular erosion/fixation because this study aimed to study the sole effect of closing TM perforation without any other confounding factor. Results The results indicate a mean hearing improvement of 12.25 dB of ABG and 10.6 dB of AC thresholds at the four frequencies of 500, 1000, 2000, and 4000 Hz. The mean of the residual ABGs at the four frequencies is 14.2 dB. There were no correlations between the amount of air conduction threshold improvement and age, gender, side of the affected ear, area of perforation, or duration of disease (p > 0.05 for all tests). Conclusion Although the rate of perforation closure in myringoplasties performed by trainees is lower than that of experienced surgeons, the audiological outcomes of myringoplasties performed by trainees under supervision were acceptable; however, further research is recommended.

Keywords

• Tympanic membrane perforation
• ENT residents
• Audiological outcomes
• Myringoplasty