Geoderma (Mar 2024)
Maize straw-based organic amendments and nitrogen fertilizer effects on soil and aggregate-associated carbon and nitrogen
Abstract
Application of organic amendments and N fertilizer can affect C and N sequestration, however, the degree to which diverse organic amendments and optimal N fertilization for matching demand for high crop productivity contributes to soil organic matter (SOM) of Cambisol in the North China Plain is not fully known. The objective was to evaluate the combined effects of annual maize straw-derived organic amendments (straw, manure, compost, biogas residue, or biochar) and in-season mineral N fertilizer amendment on soil organic carbon (SOC) and total N (TN) accumulation and thermal stability in bulk soils and physically isolated soil aggregate fractions in a long-term field experiment on the North China Plain. Application of organic amendments either alone or with N increased the proportion of macroaggregates (+62 to 137 %), aggregate mean weight diameter (+50 to 106 %), SOC (+38 to 206 %) and TN (+13 to 52 %) contents in bulk soil. The organic amendments and N fertilizer additions also increased SOC and TN contents in each of the isolated fractions: macroaggregates (+119 to 851 % for SOC, +109 to 237 % for TN) and microaggregates (+42 to 192 % for SOC and +30 to 145 % for TN), total fine particulate organic matter (T fPOM, +143 to 891 % for T fPOM-SOC, +129 to 549 % for T fPOM-TN) and total silt + clay within aggregates (53–139 % for SOC and 20–106 % for TN). Biochar resulted in the largest increase in SOC contents and improved soil aggregation without N fertilization, but fertilization greatly decreased these responses. The majority of the accumulated C and N occurred in the total silt + clay fractions, making up 50–90 % of total SOC and 79–96 % of total TN. Total fine POM and total silt + clay within aggregates contributed to 40–78 % and 10–56 % of SOC, 28–60 % and 37–71 % of TN increase between soil with and without organic amendments. Our results suggested that C and N retained in T fPOM and silt + clay fractions within aggregates were important mechanisms for C and N stabilization. Substitution of annual above-ground litter with biochar with or without mineral N fertilizer was the most effective way for SOM build up and stabilization under a wheat/maize system in the North China Plain, while manure, compost and biogas residue resulted in little to no increases of SOM in bulk soils and physically isolated aggregate fractions compared to straw amendment. Besides the effects of each amendment type on SOC, the different recovery rates of the various amendments, which determines the total quantity of each amendment that can be produced, should be taken into consideration in decisions about maize residue management at the regional scale in the North China Plain.
