Effects of a firebreak on plants and wildlife at Pine Hill, a biodiversity hotspot, El Dorado County, California

Abstract

We examined the effects of hand clearing and pile burning of chaparral on plants and wildlife on the perimeter of Pine Hill 1–2 years after clearing. Pine Hill is home to four federally listed plant species, necessitating botanical surveys prior to clearing activities to prevent harming these species. We found over 65 new locations for the listed plants. We compared vegetation within burn scars, in cleared only plots, and in intact chaparral (control) and the germination and survival of a listed species, Ceanothus roderickii (Pine Hill Ceanothus). The density of C. roderickii seedlings was far lower in the cleared, unburned treatment than in the burned treatments, while mature C. roderickii was only present in unburned treatments and mature chaparral. Intact chaparral had higher cover but lower species richness of both native and exotic species than all disturbed treatments. The cleared only treatment had almost three times the cover by exotic grasses as did the burned treatments, and cover by presumably palatable, native and exotic species, was almost twice that of the burned treatments; mature chaparral contained few palatable plants, i.e. those identified as having wildlife value by Conrad (1987). Increased availability of palatable plants in treated areas may have contributed to 3–4 times higher probabilities of detection by cameras of herbivores in treated versus intact chaparral; which may have attracted smaller predators (bobcats [Lynx rufus] and gray foxes [Urocyon cinereoargenteus]) that were positively associated with western grey squirrel (Sciurus griseus) detections. Large carnivore detections were higher in areas with higher mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) detections. Larger animals (pumas [Puma concolor], black bears [Ursus americanus], and mule deer) were detected 2–4 times more in treated areas, likely due to the physical impediment of mature chaparral. Invasion of nonnative grasses and increased wildlife usage may have been accelerated through the creation of firebreaks; continued monitoring will investigate long-term effects.

Keywords

• california
• chaparral
• firebreak
• fire cued
• gabbro
• fuel reduction
• obligate seeder
• rare plants
• resprouter
• wildlife response to fire