F1000Research (Jun 2020)

Measuring development assistance for health systems strengthening and health security: an analysis using the Creditor Reporting System database [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]

  • Indermit Gill,
  • Jessica Kraus,
  • Hugo Petitjean,
  • Marco Schäferhoff,
  • Kenan Karakulah,
  • Jessica Hale,
  • Estuardo Pineda,
  • Gavin Yamey,
  • Chris Kardish,
  • Naomi Beyeler,
  • Francesca Sanders,
  • Rachel Nugent,
  • Sara Fewer,
  • Ben Oppenheim,
  • Dean T. Jamison

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 9

Abstract

Read online

Background: Health systems strengthening (HSS) and health security are two pillars of universal health coverage (UHC). Investments in these areas are essential for meeting the Sustainable Development Goals and are of heightened relevance given the emergence of the 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19). This study aims to generate information on development assistance for health (DAH) for these areas, including how to track it and how funding levels align with country needs. Methods: We developed a framework to analyze the amount of DAH disbursed in 2015 for the six building blocks of the health system (‘system-wide HSS’) plus health security (emergency preparedness, risk management, and response) at both the global (transnational) and country level. We reviewed 2,427 of 32,801 DAH activities in the Creditor Reporting System (CRS) database (80% of the total value of disbursements in 2015) and additional public information sources. Additional aid activities were identified through a keyword search. Results: In 2015, we estimated that US$3.1 billion (13.4%) of the US$22.9 billion of DAH captured in the CRS database was for system-wide HSS and health security: US$2.5 billion (10.9%) for system-wide HSS, mostly for infrastructure, and US$0.6 billion (2.5%) for system-wide health security. US$567.1 million (2.4%) was invested in supporting these activities at the global level. If responses to individual health emergencies are included, 7.5% of total DAH (US$1.7B) was for health security. We found a correlation between DAH for HSS and maternal mortality rates, and we interpret this as evidence that HSS aid generally flowed to countries with greater need. Conclusions: Achieving UHC by 2030 will require greater investments in system-wide HSS and proactive health emergency preparedness. It may be appropriate for donors to more prominently consider country needs and global functions when investing in health security and HSS.

Keywords