Symmetry (Mar 2023)

Comparing the Min–Max–Median/IQR Approach with the Min–Max Approach, Logistic Regression and XGBoost, Maximising the Youden Index

  • Rocío Aznar-Gimeno,
  • Luis M. Esteban,
  • Gerardo Sanz,
  • Rafael del-Hoyo-Alonso

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/sym15030756
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 15, no. 3
p. 756

Abstract

Read online

Although linearly combining multiple variables can provide adequate diagnostic performance, certain algorithms have the limitation of being computationally demanding when the number of variables is sufficiently high. Liu et al. proposed the min–max approach that linearly combines the minimum and maximum values of biomarkers, which is computationally tractable and has been shown to be optimal in certain scenarios. We developed the Min–Max–Median/IQR algorithm under Youden index optimisation which, although more computationally intensive, is still approachable and includes more information. The aim of this work is to compare the performance of these algorithms with well-known Machine Learning algorithms, namely logistic regression and XGBoost, which have proven to be efficient in various fields of applications, particularly in the health sector. This comparison is performed on a wide range of different scenarios of simulated symmetric or asymmetric data, as well as on real clinical diagnosis data sets. The results provide useful information for binary classification problems of better algorithms in terms of performance depending on the scenario.

Keywords