How Much Experience is Required to Acquire the Skills to Independently Perform Spine Surgery? What Milestones are Needed for Successful Surgery?

Abstract

Ryunosuke Fukushi,1 Atsushi Teramoto,1 Mitsunori Yoshimoto,1 Naohisa Miyakoshi,2 Daisuke Kudo,2 Makoto Emori,1 Yoichi Shimada,2 Toshihiko Yamashita1 1Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Sapporo Medical University School of Medicine, Sapporo, Japan; 2Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Akita University School, Akita, JapanCorrespondence: Ryunosuke Fukushi, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Sapporo Medical University School of Medicine, S1 W16, Sapporo, Hokkaido, 060-8543, Japan, Tel [phone], Fax [phone], Email [email protected]: To assess the number of surgeries needed to acquire the necessary skills to perform spine surgery independently.Patients and Methods: A questionnaire on 12 different spinal procedures was sent to orthopedic surgeons affiliated with the spine teams of orthopedic departments at either the Akita University or Sapporo Medical University. Participants were asked to identify whether they (A) could independently perform each procedure, (B) could perform each procedure with the assistance of a senior doctor, or (C) were unable to perform each procedure. Those whose response was (A) were asked how many surgeries were required to acquire the necessary skills. Those who responded to (B) or (C) were asked how many surgeries they believed were required to acquire the skills necessary to operate independently. Participants also responded to 10 questions on surgical training techniques and rated the usefulness of each method.Results: A total of 55 spine surgeons responded to the questionnaire. Group A required significantly fewer surgeries in the following categories to become independent than required Group C: upper cervical spine surgery (7.3/19.3), anterior cervical decompression/fusion (6.7/28.8), posterior cervical decompression/fusion (9.5/27.3), lumbar discectomy (12.6/26.7), endoscopic lumbar discectomy (10.2/24.2), spinal tumor resection (6.5/37.2), and spinal kyphosis surgery (10.3/32.3). Over 80% of participants responded that the following were effective methods: “surgeries where a senior doctor is the main surgeon, and the respondent is the assistant and observer”; “surgeries where the respondent is the main surgeon, and a senior doctor is an assistant”; “self-study using surgery manuals, articles, and textbooks”; and “training through video surgery sessions”.Conclusion: Surgeons who do not perform specific procedures independently require more surgical experience than those who operate independently. Our results may help develop more efficient training methods for spine surgeons.Keywords: surgical experience, surgical training, training system, inexperienced spine surgeons

Keywords

• surgical experience
• surgical training
• training system
• inexperienced spine surgeons