Biomechanical effect of implant design on four implants supporting mandibular full-arch fixed dentures: In vitro test and finite element analysis

Abstract

Background/Purpose: Impact of the implant shape on the biomechanical performance of all-on-four treatment of dental implant is still unclear. This study evaluated the all-on-four treatment with four osseointegrated implants in terms of the biomechanical effects of implant design and loading position on the implant and surrounding bone by using both in vitro strain gauge tests and three-dimensional (3D) finite element (FE) analyses. Methods: Both in vitro and 3D FE models were constructed with placing NobelSpeedy and NobelActive implants as well as a titanium framework in an edentulous jawbone based on the concept of all-on-four treatment. Three types of loads were applied: at the central incisor area (loading position 1) and at the molar regions with (loading position 2) and without (loading position 3) the denture cantilever. For the in vitro tests, the principal bone strains were recorded by rosette strain gauges and statistically evaluated using Wilcoxon's rank-sum test. The 3D FE simulations analyzed the peak von-Mises stresses in the implant and surrounding cortical bone. Results: The peak stress and strain in the surrounding bone were typically 36–62% (3D FE analysis) and 47–57% (in vitro test) (p < 0.001)higher for loading position 3 than for loading positions 1 and 2. Between those two implant designs, the bone strains and bone stresses did not differ significantly. Conclusion: For all-on-four treatment with four osseointegrated dental implants, altering the implant design does not appear to affect the biomechanical performance of the entire treatment, especially in terms of the stresses and strains in the surrounding bone.

Keywords

• All-on-four treatment with four osseointegrated dental implants
• Implant design
• Loading position
• In vitro strain gauge test
• Finite element analysis