Sedimentation dynamics of triply twisted Möbius bands: Geometry versus topology

Abstract

We explore the sedimentation dynamics of triply twisted Möbius bands, each characterized by threefold rotational symmetry but distinguished by its construction and intrinsic geometrical properties. Three types of bands are considered: one with vanishing Gaussian curvature, constructed by isometrically deforming flat rectangular strips through bending without stretching; and two with negative Gaussian curvature, one being constructed by isometrically deforming helicoids. Experiment on these three types of bands, with a focus on varying aspect ratios, reveals a singular phenomenon: while the spin directions of bands not derived from helicoids spin in directions consistent with their inherent chirality, bands derived from helicoids exhibit an aspect-ratio-dependent spin, pointing to the existence of a critical aspect ratio at which geometric factors dominate over chiral influences. Supported by numerical simulations and a detailed analysis of the resistance tensors, we propose the unique response of bands derived from helicoids originates from a complex interaction among geometry, topology, and hydrodynamics. Two explanations are offered for the chiral transition observed in bands derived from helicoid. First, this transition may parallel the dynamics of superhelices, for which competing chiralities influence rotational behavior. Second, the unique geometrical properties of bands derived from helicoids, coupled with deviations between the rotation axis and the local symmetry axis, may underlie the observed aspect-ratio-dependent chiral transition. Our study underscores the significant role of geometrical and topological nuances in determining the behavior of chiral objects suspended in fluids. In addition to offering transformative potential across diverse fields, it promises advancements in mixing, separation processes, and innovative passive swimmers.