Water Supply (Jan 2022)

The challenges of predicting pipe failures in clean water networks: a view from current practice

  • N. A. Barton,
  • S. H. Hallett,
  • S. R. Jude

DOI
https://doi.org/10.2166/ws.2021.255
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 22, no. 1
pp. 527 – 541

Abstract

Read online

Pipe failure models can aid proactive management decisions and help target pipes in need of preventative repair or replacement. Yet, there are several uncertainties and challenges that arise when developing models, resulting in discord between failure predictions and those observed in the field. This paper aims to raise awareness of the main challenges, uncertainties, and potential advances discussed in key themes, supported by a series of semi-structured interviews undertaken with water professionals. The main discussion topics include data management, data limitations, pre-processing difficulties, model scalability and future opportunities and challenges. Improving data quality and quantity is key in improving pipe failure models. Technological advances in the collection of continuous real-time data from ubiquitous smart networks offer opportunities to improve data collection, whilst machine learning and data analytics methods offer a chance to improve future predictions. In some instances, technological approaches may provide better solutions to tackling short term proactive management. Yet, there remains an opportunity for pipe failure models to provide valuable insights for long-term rehabilitation and replacement planning. HIGHLIGHTS A variety of pipe failure model challenges and uncertainties are discussed.; Industry professional interviews provide deeper understanding of the issues.; Data management, quality, pre-processing and scalability influence modelling.; Future opportunities include the benefits of real-time data, data analytics and machine learning.;

Keywords