European Urology Open Science (May 2024)

Preparing for the Worst: Management and Predictive Factors of Open Conversion During Minimally Invasive Renal Tumor Surgery (UroCCR-135 Study)

  • Nicolas Branger,
  • Nicolas Doumerc,
  • Thibaut Waeckel,
  • Pierre Bigot,
  • Louis Surlemont,
  • Sophie Knipper,
  • Géraldine Pignot,
  • François Audenet,
  • Frank Bruyère,
  • Alexis Fontenil,
  • Bastien Parier,
  • Cécile Champy,
  • Morgan Rouprêt,
  • Jean-Jacques Patard,
  • François Henon,
  • Gaëlle Fiard,
  • Julien Guillotreau,
  • Jean-Baptiste Beauval,
  • Constance Michel,
  • Simon Bernardeau,
  • Fayek Taha,
  • Richard Mallet,
  • Frederic Panthier,
  • Laurent Guy,
  • Louis Vignot,
  • Zine-Eddine Khene,
  • Jean-Christophe Bernhard

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 63
pp. 89 – 95

Abstract

Read online

Background and objective: Data regarding open conversion (OC) during minimally invasive surgery (MIS) for renal tumors are reported from big databases, without precise description of the reason and management of OC. The objective of this study was to describe the rate, reasons, and perioperative outcomes of OC in a cohort of patients who underwent MIS for renal tumor initially. The secondary objective was to find the factors associated with OC. Methods: Between 2008 and 2022, of the 8566 patients included in the UroCCR project prospective database (NCT03293563), who underwent laparoscopic or robot-assisted minimally invasive partial (MIPN) or radical (MIRN) nephrectomy, 163 experienced OC. Each center was contacted to enlighten the context of OC: “emergency OC” implied an immediate life-threatening situation not reasonably manageable with MIS, otherwise “elective OC”. To evaluate the predictive factors of OC, a 2:1 paired cohort on the UroCCR database was used. Key findings and limitations: The incidence rate of OC was 1.9% for all cases of MIS, 2.9% for MIRN, and 1.4% for MIPN. OC procedures were mostly elective (82.2%). The main reason for OC was a failure to progress due to anatomical difficulties (42.9%). Five patients (3.1%) died within 90 d after surgery. Increased body mass index (BMI; odds ratio [OR]: 1.05, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.01–1.09, p = 0.009) and cT stage (OR: 2.22, 95% CI: 1.24–4.25, p = 0.008) were independent predictive factors of OC. Conclusions and clinical implications: In MIS for renal tumors, OC was a rare event (1.9%), caused by various situations, leading to impaired perioperative outcomes. Emergency OC occurred once every 300 procedures. Increased BMI and cT stage were independent predictive factors of OC. Patient summary: The incidence rate of open conversion (OC) in minimally invasive surgery for renal tumors is low. Only 20% of OC procedures occur in case of emergency, and others are caused by various situations. Increased body mass index and cT stage were independent predictive factors of OC.

Keywords