What Makes a “Muslim Intellectual”? On the Pros and Cons of a Category

Abstract

At its core, this essay contains a substantiated plea for bringing about conceptual clarity to the notion of “Muslim intellectual”, which the frequent and highly ideologically charged public usage of this term seems to distort. In search for a sound analytical concept of “intellectual” first, relevant sociological and philosophical deliberations are highlighted, indicating that both of their notions differ to such an extent that their applicability to academic pursuit must be doubted. Yet, by discussing some considerations by a Study of Islam open to the approaches of the Social Sciences a possible framework for an analytically meaningful concept of “Muslim intellectual” is presented. At the same time, however, arguments are presented for why those contemporary Muslim thinkers who are usually credited with being “Muslim intellectuals” would hardly fit the analytical criteria for such label.

Keywords

• Analytical Category
• Object Concept
• ʿulamāʾ
• mufakkirūn
• Nineteenth Century
• Structural Change
• Ideology