Remote Sensing (Jan 2023)
Comparison of Lake Extraction and Classification Methods for the Tibetan Plateau Based on Topographic-Spectral Information
Abstract
Accurate identification and extraction of lake boundaries are the basis of the accurate assessment of lake changes and their responses to climate change. To reduce the effects of lake ice and snow cover, mountain shadows, cloud and fog shielding, alluvial and proluvial deposits, and shoals on the extraction of lake boundaries on the Tibetan Plateau, this study developed an RNSS water index to increase the contrast between the lake and similar surface objects of the spectral curve, and constructed a new method flow for lake extraction on the Tibetan Plateau based on image synthesis, topographic-spectral feature indexes, and machine learning algorithms. The lake extraction effects of three common machine learning classification algorithms were compared: the Cart decision tree, random forest (RF), and gradient boosting decision tree (GBDT). The results show that the new lake extraction method based on topographic-spectral characteristics and the GBDT classification method had the highest extraction accuracy for Tibetan Plateau lakes in 2016 and 2021. Its overall accuracy, Kappa coefficient, user’s accuracy, and producer’s accuracy for 2016 and 2021 were 99.81%, 0.887, 83.55%, 94.67% and 99.88%, 0.933, 89.18%, 98.24%, respectively, and the total area of lake extraction was the most consistent with the validation datasets. The three classification methods can effectively extract lakes covered by ice and snow, and the extraction effect was ranked as GBDT > RF > Cart. The lake extraction effect under mountain shadow was ranked as Cart > GBDT > RF, and the lake extraction effect under alluvial deposits and shoals was ranked as GBDT > RF > Cart. The results may provide technical support for extracting lakes from long time series and reveal the impact of climate change on Tibetan Plateau lakes.
Keywords
