Toxicology Reports (Dec 2023)
Heavy metal contamination and health risk assessment of horticultural crops in two sub-cities of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Abstract
This particular study was aimed to establish the level of heavy metals in different horticultural crops cultivated by irrigation and the soil in two sub-cities of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and quantitatively assess the health treat they pose for the consumer. A total of 151 vegetable samples comprised of lettuce (Lactuca sativa), cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitate), cucumber (Cucumis sativus), potato (Solanum tuberosum), parsley (Petroselinum crispum), Swiss chard (Beta vulgaris subsp. vulgaris), beetroot (Beta vulgaris), green onion (Allium porrum L.) and 28 soil samples were collected for this study. Six toxic elements were analyzed using microwave plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (MP-AES) after microwave assisted digestion of the samples. The concentrations of examined trace elements in vegetables (mg/kg) were found in the range of 5.50–93.00 for zinc; below detection limit (BDL)− 18.50 for copper; BDL-2.50 for nickel; BDL-17.00 for lead; 5.00–4256.50 for manganese and 22.00–8708.00 for iron. Considering the mean Pb content values, all vegetables exceeded the maximum permissible level set by the joint FAO/WHO commission in both irrigation sites. In case of Mn parsley, swiss chard, and green onion all from site two exceeded the maximum allowable values. With the exception of potato from irrigation site one, all vegetables exceeded the maximum permissible limit set for Fe concentration and out of which parsley, swiss chard, and green onion, all from site two, exceeded by more than double amount. The same trend is observed for the concentration of Mn and Fe in the soil samples. In fact, in both irrigation sites their concentration exceeded the allowable limits set by United Nation Environment Program (UNEP) for agricultural soils. The metal pollution load index revealed that in most of the vegetables studied the overall pollution load of trace metals were higher in Kolfe Keranyo irrigation site. The risk assessment study using indices like estimation of daily/weekly dietary exposure, hazard quotient and metal pollution load index all suggested consumption of the studied vegetables poses a significant health risk for the consumer. For adults the calculated target hazard quotient for the trace element Pb is higher than 1 (one) for all of studied vegetables ranging from 11.086 (cucumber) to 17.881 (beetroot) with a 98.216% and 98.464% contribution to the hazard indices, respectively. For a child consumer, Mn showed a higher target hazard quotient vales ranged from 0.0107 (cucumber) to 0.0495 (green onion) with a 70.86% and 88.85% contribution to the total hazard indices, respectively. The soil pollution indices also indicated that the degree of metal enrichment in soils and sediments are higher than the allowable limits. Therefore, a prompt action is required to curb the problem and ensure the public safety along the food system line.
