Error Decomposition of CRA40-Land and ERA5-Land Reanalysis Precipitation Products over the Yongding River Basin in North China

Abstract

Long-term and high-resolution reanalysis precipitation datasets provide important support for research on climate change, hydrological forecasting, etc. The comprehensive evaluation of the error performances of the newly released ERA5-Land and CRA40-Land reanalysis precipitation datasets over the Yongding River Basin in North China was based on the two error decomposition schemes, namely, decomposition of the total mean square error into systematic and random errors and decomposition of the total precipitation bias into hit bias, missed precipitation, and false precipitation. Then, the error features of the two datasets and precipitation intensity and terrain effects against error features were analyzed in this study. The results indicated the following: (1) Based on the decomposition approach of systematic and random errors, the total error of ERA5-Land is generally greater than that of CRA40-Land. Additionally, the proportion of random errors was higher in summer and over mountainous areas, specifically, the ERA5-Land accounts for more than 75%, while the other was less than 70%; (2) Considering the decomposition method of hit, missed, and false bias, the total precipitation bias of ERA5-Land and CRA40-Land was consistent with the hit bias. The magnitude of missed precipitation and false precipitation was less than the hit bias. (3) When the precipitation intensity is less than 38 mm/d, the random errors of ERA5-Land and CRA40-Land are larger than the systematic error. The relationship between precipitation intensity and hit, missed, and false precipitation is complicated, for the hit bias of ERA5-L is always smaller than that of CRA40-L, and the missed precipitation and false precipitation are larger than those ofCRA40-L when the precipitation is small. The error of ERA5-Land and CRA40-Land was significantly correlated with elevation. A comprehensive understanding of the error features of the two reanalysis precipitation datasets is valuable for error correction and the construction of a multi-source fusion model with gauge-based and satellite-based precipitation datasets.

Keywords

• reanalysis precipitation datasets
• ERA5-land
• CRA40-land
• error decomposition
• precipitation intensity
• terrain