Comparison of Three Methods for Skeleton Age Estimation

Abstract

ObjectiveTo find the appropriate method for age estimation for different ages and sexes.MethodsThe costal cartilage， sternum and pubic symphysis of 91 unknowns from 2000 to 2020 from the Forensic Department of the Criminal Investigation Team of Shanghai Public Security Bureau were collected. Costal cartilage， sternal and pubic symphysis inferences were used to estimate the age， and the consistency between the estimated results and the actual physiological age of the unknowns was tested. The accuracy of age estimation of different samples was compared， and the relationship between accuracy and age and sex was analyzed.ResultsUsing the costal cartilage method， the inference errors of males， females and the whole population under 40 years old were （0.608±2.298） years， （0.429±1.867） years and （0.493±2.040） years， while those over 40 years old were （-1.707±3.770） years， （-3.286±4.078） years and （-2.625±4.029） years. The differences between different age groups in these three populations were statistically significant （P<0.05）. Using the sternum method， the inference errors of males and females under the age of 40 were （0.921±3.019） years and （0.452±1.451） years， while those over the age of 40 were （-5.903±5.088） years and （-1.429±2.227） years. The differences between different age groups in males and females were statistically significant （P<0.05）. Using the pubic symphysis method， the inference errors of males and females under 40 years old were （-0.204±1.876） years and （0.238±2.477） years， while those over 40 years old were （1.500±2.156） years and （-2.643±4.270） years. The differences between different age groups in males and females were statistically significant （P<0.05）. Using the sternum method and pubic symphysis method for age estimation of over 40 years old， the difference between different sexes was statistically significant （P<0.05）.ConclusionAll three methods of age estimation are stable and effective and more accurate for people under 40 years old. For age estimation of unknowns over 40 years old， the pubic symphysis method is preferred in males and the sternum method is preferred in females.

Keywords

• forensic anthropology
• age estimation by skeleton
• costal cartilage
• pubic symphysis
• sternum