Enseñanza & Teaching (Dec 2017)

Design and reliability of a didactic inphographic rubric assessment

  • Yunuen Ixchel GUZMÁN-CEDILLO,
  • Natalia LIMA-VILLEDA,
  • José Manuel MEZA-CANO

DOI
https://doi.org/10.14201/et20173521736
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 35, no. 2
pp. 17 – 36

Abstract

Read online

The objective of this study is to describe design, validity process and reliability of a rubric assessment to evaluate didactic infographics quality. Participants were fifteen judges who participate in different moments of elaboration rubric process; it was made in three process phases: design, settings and reliability determination. Content validity was obtained by percentage agreement between 3 judges by component of the rubric; likewise a Krippendorff’s alpha were applied (a = .710) in pilot assessment with 5 infographics in order to set possible writings contradictions between components and criteria of performance. The intern consistence was determined by Cronbach’s alpha (? = .806) in 22 infographics gradation. An Intraclass correlation coefficient icc (a = .909) was applied to 6 judges qualifications also a Krippendorff’s alpha (a = .538) both of them in ordinal levels. The rubric is composed by 9 components, 3 performance levels, definitions of each component and assignments how to use the rubric. Results suggest the rubric is valid and reliable to grade quality of didactic infographic.

Keywords