Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution (Jul 2021)
The Evidential Statistics of Genetic Assembly: Bootstrapping a Reference Sequence
Abstract
The reference sequences play an essential role in genome assembly, like type specimens in taxonomy. Those references are also samples obtained at some time and location with a specific method. How can we evaluate or discriminate uncertainties of the reference itself and assembly methods? Here we bootstrapped 50 random read data sets from a small circular genome of a Escherichia coli bacteriophage, phiX174, and tried to reconstruct the reference with 14 free assembly programs. Nine out of 14 assembly programs were capable of circular genome reconstruction. Unicycler correctly reconstructed the reference for 44 out of 50 data sets, but each reconstructed contig of the failed six data sets had minor defects. The other assembly software could reconstruct the reference with minor defects. The defect regions differed among the assembly programs, and the defect locations were far from randomly distributed in the reference genome. All contigs of Trinity included one, but Minia had two perfect copies other than an imperfect reference copy. The centroid of contigs for assembly programs except Unicycler differed from the reference with 75bases at most. Nonmetric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) plots of the centroids indicated that even the reference sequence was located slightly off from the estimated location of the true reference. We propose that the combination of bootstrapping a reference, making consensus contigs as centroids in an edit distance, and NMDS plotting will provide an evidential statistic way of genetic assembly for non-fragmented base sequences.
Keywords
