Gates Open Research (Nov 2020)

Integration of health solutions into government systems: a tool for assessing readiness [version 1; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]

  • Emily Lawrence,
  • Amanda Pain,
  • Jessica Crawford,
  • Kim Baker,
  • Ruth Bechtel,
  • Aida L. Coelho,
  • Alvo Ofumane,
  • Joseph Roussel,
  • Bvudzai Magadzire

DOI
https://doi.org/10.12688/gatesopenres.13193.1
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 4

Abstract

Read online

Government partnerships are essential for many health solutions to sustain impact at scale, particularly in low-resource settings where strengthening health systems is critical for Universal Health Coverage. Many non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and funders ultimately want solutions to be integrated into public health systems by transitioning solution ownership, management and/or operation to government. However, NGOs and their government partners have limited guidance on how to effectively determine when a solution is ready to transition in a way that will maintain impact long term. To address this need, VillageReach developed the Transition Readiness Assessment (TRA) based on our transition to government theoretical framework. The framework was developed to define both factors related to a solution, as well as external influences that affect a solution’s success. The framework identifies seven dimensions of solution readiness: the political, economic, and social context; solution design; resource availability; financial management; government strategy; government policy and regulations; and organizational management. The TRA measures those dimensions and assigns each one a readiness score. We developed the framework and TRA for VillageReach solutions, as well as to share with government partners and stakeholders. This Open Letter outlines the TRA development, details empirical examples from applying the tool on two VillageReach solutions, and presents recommendations based on our lessons learned. Stakeholders working to transition solutions to government can utilize both the TRA and our lessons.