Frontiers in Computer Science (Feb 2023)

Long-term effect of the absence of a companion robot on older adults: A preliminary pilot study

  • Ryuji Yamazaki,
  • Shuichi Nishio,
  • Yuma Nagata,
  • Yuto Satake,
  • Maki Suzuki,
  • Hideki Kanemoto,
  • Miyae Yamakawa,
  • David Figueroa,
  • Hiroshi Ishiguro,
  • Hiroshi Ishiguro,
  • Manabu Ikeda

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fcomp.2023.1129506
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 5

Abstract

Read online

Robotic assistive technology for frail older adults has drawn attention, along with raising ethical concerns. The ethical implications of a robot's usage have been characterized in the literature as detrimental, such as emotional deception, unhealthy attachment, and reduced human contact from a deontological perspective. These concerns require practical investigations, although the long-term effect of robot usage on older adults remains uncertain. Our longitudinal study aimed to investigate how older adults with cognitive decline could be affected by using a robot for communication in their homes and how this situation could be reflected in possible emotional attachment to the robot i.e., emotional distress from the robot being taken away once they had become attached to it. We selected 13 older adults living alone and set up a humanoid robot in their homes with whom they could interact at any time for a period of 1–4 months. Questionnaire results indicated participants had a close attachment to the robots even after they were taken away. Interviews revealed that participants became distressed without the robots; however, despite the distress caused by feeling lonely, participants reported that their relationships with the robots were meaningful and that they were satisfied with the memories of having had the robot as a companion. The results raised new questions for further investigation into issues that should be addressed and potential factors affecting the user's adaptation processes. Regarding the consequences of the use of a companion robot, it is important to evaluate the positive aspects of the robot's usage including the emotional support lasting after it was no longer available and other effects on the users. Accordingly, we emphasize the significance of real-world exploration into the effects on the users as well as theoretical reflection on appropriate robot usage.

Keywords