Nanocrystalline Apatites: Post-Immersion Acidification and How to Avoid It—Application to Antibacterial Bone Substitutes

Abstract

Biomimetic nanocrystalline apatites analogous to bone mineral can be prepared using soft chemistry. Due to their high similarity to bone apatite, as opposed to stoichiometric hydroxyapatite for example, they now represent an appealing class of compounds to produce bioactive ceramics for which drug delivery and ion exchange abilities have been described extensively. However, immersion in aqueous media of dried non-carbonated biomimetic apatite crystals may generate an acidification event, which is often disregarded and not been clarified to-date. Yet, this acidification process could limit their further development if it is not understood and overcome if necessary. This may, for example, alter biological test outcomes, during their evaluation as bone repair materials, due to potentially deleterious effects of the acidic environment on cells, especially in in vitro static conditions. In this study, we explore the origins of this acidification phenomenon based on complementary experimental data and we point out the central role of the hydrated ionic layer present on apatite nanocrystals. We then propose a practical strategy to circumvent this acidification effect using an adequate post-precipitation equilibration step that was optimized. Using this enutralization protocol, we then showed the possibility of performing (micro)biological assessments on such compounds and provide an illustration with the examples of post-equilibrated Cu2+- and Ag+-doped nanocrystalline apatites. We demonstrate their non-cytotoxicity to osteoblast cells and their antibacterial features as tested versus five major pathogens involved in bone infections, therefore pointing to their relevance in the field of antibacterial bone substitutes. The preliminary in vivo implantation of a relevant sample in a rat’s calvarial defect confirmed its biocompatibility and the absence of adverse reaction. Understanding and eliminating this technical barrier should help promoting biomimetic apatites as a genuine new class of biomaterial-producing compounds for bone regeneration applications, e.g., with antibacterial features, far from being solely considered as “laboratory curiosities”.

Keywords

• nanocrystalline apatite
• surface features
• acidification effect
• surface equilibration
• antibacterial bone substitute
• copper