We compare the suitability of various magnesium-based liquid metal alloy ion sources (LMAISs) for scalable focused-ion-beam (FIB) implantation doping of GaN. We consider GaMg, MgSO4●7H2O, MgZn, AlMg, and AuMgSi alloys. Although issues of oxidation (GaMg), decomposition (MgSO4●7H2O), and excessive vapor pressure (MgZn and AlMg) were encountered, the AuMgSi alloy LMAIS operating in a Wien-filtered FIB column emits all Mg isotopes in singly and doubly charged ionization states. We discuss the operating conditions to achieve <20 nm spot size Mg FIB implantation and present Mg depth profile data from time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry. We also provide insight into implantation damage and recovery based on cathodoluminescence spectroscopy before and after rapid thermal processing. Prospects for incorporating the Mg LMAIS into high-power electronic device fabrication are also discussed.