Transphyseal Humeral Separations: An Often-Missed Fracture

Abstract

Background: Transphyseal humeral separations (TPHS) are rare injuries often associated with non-accidental trauma, necessitating accurate diagnosis. This study aims to assess the accuracy of diagnosis of TPHS. Methods: A retrospective review was conducted at five academic pediatric institutions to identify all surgically treated TPHS in patients up to 4 years of age over a 25-year period. Demographics, misdiagnosis rates, and reported misdiagnoses were noted. Comparative analyses were performed to analyze the effects of patient age and injury mechanism on misdiagnosis rates. Results: Seventy-nine patients (average age: 17.4 months) were identified, with injury mechanisms including accidental trauma (n = 49), non-accidental trauma (n = 21), Cesarean-section (n = 6), and vaginal delivery (n = 3). Neither age nor injury mechanism were significantly associated with diagnostic accuracy in the emergency department (ED)/consulting physician group. ED/consulting physicians achieved an accurate diagnosis 46.7% of the time, while radiologists achieved an accurate diagnosis 26.7% of the time. Diagnostic accuracy did not correlate with Child Protective Services (CPS) involvement or with a delay in surgery of more than 24 h. However, a significant correlation (p = 0.03) was observed between injury mechanism and misdiagnosis rates. Conclusion: This multicenter analysis is the largest study assessing TPHS misdiagnosis rates, highlighting the need for raising awareness and considering advanced imaging or orthopedic consultation for accurate diagnosis. This also reminds orthopedic surgeons to always have vigilant assessment in treating pediatric elbow injuries. Level of Evidence: Level III–Retrospective Cohort Study.

Keywords

• transphyseal humeral separation
• misdiagnosis
• elbow fracture
• non-accidental trauma
• child abuse