Clinical study outcomes in IgA nephropathy: A systematic literature review and narrative synthesis.

Abstract

IntroductionIgA nephropathy (IgAN) is an inflammatory kidney disease which, if left untreated, often progresses to kidney failure (KF). This systematic literature review identifies, collates, summarizes, and assesses the quality of clinical trial data describing the efficacy of therapies used for IgAN.MethodsOvid Embase, PubMed, CENTRAL, and the Cochrane database of systematic reviews were searched on October 18th, 2021, and updated on December 12th, 2023. Electronic searches were supplemented with manual searches of key conferences, clinical trial registries, and bibliography screening. PRISMA and Cochrane guidelines were followed.ResultsA total of 6710 references were identified (electronic and manual searches), of which 6483 were excluded. This resulted in 254 references reporting 183 studies which met our inclusion criteria. The majority of these IgAN studies (98/183 studies [60%]) had a non-randomized or single-arm design and/or a small population size or focused on dietary and traditional medicine, resulting in a high risk of bias and necessitated additional filtering to prioritize larger (n>30) randomized assessment of pharmacological interventions reporting key clinical outcomes. This additional filtering resulted in 76 randomized controlled trials (100 references) selected for narrative synthesis; 60 reported proteinuria outcomes and 18 reported estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) outcomes.ConclusionsUntil recently, the evidence has been mixed or inconsistent across studies for the efficacy of IgAN treatments in reducing proteinuria or slowing eGFR decline due to a high risk of bias in many included studies. The latest large, phase 3 NefIgArd (NCT03643965) and PROTECT (NCT03762850) clinical trials have demonstrated a meaningful reduction in proteinuria and eGFR decline for patients with IgAN receiving targeted-release formulation budesonide (TRF-B) or sparsentan. Results from other high-quality randomized controlled trials with a follow-up period of at least 2 years are still required to better support advancements in the management of IgAN.