Methods in Ecology and Evolution (Oct 2023)
A deep learning approach to photo–identification demonstrates high performance on two dozen cetacean species
- Philip T. Patton,
- Ted Cheeseman,
- Kenshin Abe,
- Taiki Yamaguchi,
- Walter Reade,
- Ken Southerland,
- Addison Howard,
- Erin M. Oleson,
- Jason B. Allen,
- Erin Ashe,
- Aline Athayde,
- Robin W. Baird,
- Charla Basran,
- Elsa Cabrera,
- John Calambokidis,
- Júlio Cardoso,
- Emma L. Carroll,
- Amina Cesario,
- Barbara J. Cheney,
- Enrico Corsi,
- Jens Currie,
- John W. Durban,
- Erin A. Falcone,
- Holly Fearnbach,
- Kiirsten Flynn,
- Trish Franklin,
- Wally Franklin,
- Bárbara Galletti Vernazzani,
- Tilen Genov,
- Marie Hill,
- David R. Johnston,
- Erin L. Keene,
- Sabre D. Mahaffy,
- Tamara L. McGuire,
- Liah McPherson,
- Catherine Meyer,
- Robert Michaud,
- Anastasia Miliou,
- Dara N. Orbach,
- Heidi C. Pearson,
- Marianne H. Rasmussen,
- William J. Rayment,
- Caroline Rinaldi,
- Renato Rinaldi,
- Salvatore Siciliano,
- Stephanie Stack,
- Beatriz Tintore,
- Leigh G. Torres,
- Jared R. Towers,
- Cameron Trotter,
- Reny Tyson Moore,
- Caroline R. Weir,
- Rebecca Wellard,
- Randall Wells,
- Kymberly M. Yano,
- Jochen R. Zaeschmar,
- Lars Bejder
Affiliations
- Philip T. Patton
- Marine Mammal Research Program, Hawai'i Institute of Marine Biology University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Kāne'ohe Hawai'i USA
- Ted Cheeseman
- Marine Ecological Research Centre Southern Cross University Lismore New South Wales Australia
- Kenshin Abe
- Preferred Networks, Inc. Chiyoda‐ku Tokyo Japan
- Taiki Yamaguchi
- Preferred Networks, Inc. Chiyoda‐ku Tokyo Japan
- Walter Reade
- Google, Kaggle San Francisco California USA
- Ken Southerland
- Happywhale.com Santa Cruz California USA
- Addison Howard
- Google, Kaggle San Francisco California USA
- Erin M. Oleson
- NOAA Fisheries Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center Honolulu Hawai'i USA
- Jason B. Allen
- Chicago Zoological Society's Sarasota Dolphin Research Program c/o Mote Marine Laboratory Sarasota Florida USA
- Erin Ashe
- Oceans Initiative Seattle Washington USA
- Aline Athayde
- Projeto Baleia à Vista (ProBaV) Ilhabela Brazil
- Robin W. Baird
- Cascadia Research Collective Olympia Washington USA
- Charla Basran
- Research Center in Húsavík University of Iceland Húsavík Iceland
- Elsa Cabrera
- Centro de Conservación Cetacea (CCC) Santiago Chile
- John Calambokidis
- Cascadia Research Collective Olympia Washington USA
- Júlio Cardoso
- Projeto Baleia à Vista (ProBaV) Ilhabela Brazil
- Emma L. Carroll
- School of Biological Sciences University of Auckland‐Waipapa Taumata Rau Auckland New Zealand
- Amina Cesario
- Tethys Research Institute Milan Italy
- Barbara J. Cheney
- School of Biological Sciences University of Aberdeen Cromarty UK
- Enrico Corsi
- Cascadia Research Collective Olympia Washington USA
- Jens Currie
- Marine Mammal Research Program, Hawai'i Institute of Marine Biology University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Kāne'ohe Hawai'i USA
- John W. Durban
- SR3, SeaLife Response, Rehabilitation and Research Des Moines Washington USA
- Erin A. Falcone
- Marine Ecology and Telemetry Research Seabeck Washington USA
- Holly Fearnbach
- SR3, SeaLife Response, Rehabilitation and Research Des Moines Washington USA
- Kiirsten Flynn
- Cascadia Research Collective Olympia Washington USA
- Trish Franklin
- Marine Ecological Research Centre Southern Cross University Lismore New South Wales Australia
- Wally Franklin
- Marine Ecological Research Centre Southern Cross University Lismore New South Wales Australia
- Bárbara Galletti Vernazzani
- Centro de Conservación Cetacea (CCC) Santiago Chile
- Tilen Genov
- Morigenos‐Slovenian Marine Mammal Society Piran Slovenia
- Marie Hill
- NOAA Fisheries Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center Honolulu Hawai'i USA
- David R. Johnston
- Marine Science Department, Te Tari Putaiao Taimoana University of Otago Otago New Zealand
- Erin L. Keene
- Marine Ecology and Telemetry Research Seabeck Washington USA
- Sabre D. Mahaffy
- Cascadia Research Collective Olympia Washington USA
- Tamara L. McGuire
- The Cook Inlet Beluga Whale Photo–ID Project Anchorage Alaska USA
- Liah McPherson
- Marine Mammal Research Program, Hawai'i Institute of Marine Biology University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Kāne'ohe Hawai'i USA
- Catherine Meyer
- School of Biological Sciences, Te Kura Mātauranga Koiora University of Auckland Auckland New Zealand
- Robert Michaud
- Groupe de Recherche et D'éducation sur les Mammifères Marins (GREMM) Tadoussac Québec Canada
- Anastasia Miliou
- Archipelagos Institute of Marine Conservation Samos Island Greece
- Dara N. Orbach
- Department of Life Sciences Texas A&M University‐Corpus Christi Corpus Christi Texas USA
- Heidi C. Pearson
- Department of Natural Sciences University of Alaska Southeast Juneau Alaska USA
- Marianne H. Rasmussen
- Research Center in Húsavík University of Iceland Húsavík Iceland
- William J. Rayment
- Department of Marine Science‐Te Tari Pūtaiao Taimoana University of Otago Dunedin New Zealand
- Caroline Rinaldi
- L'association Evasion Tropicale Bouillante Guadeloupe
- Renato Rinaldi
- L'association Evasion Tropicale Bouillante Guadeloupe
- Salvatore Siciliano
- Departamento de Ciências Biológicas Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública/Fiocruz Rio de Janeiro Brazil
- Stephanie Stack
- Pacific Whale Foundation Wailuku Hawai'i USA
- Beatriz Tintore
- Archipelagos Institute of Marine Conservation Samos Island Greece
- Leigh G. Torres
- Marine Mammal Institute, Oregon State University Newport Oregon USA
- Jared R. Towers
- Bay Cetology Alert Bay British Columbia Canada
- Cameron Trotter
- School of Engineering Newcastle University Newcastle UK
- Reny Tyson Moore
- Chicago Zoological Society's Sarasota Dolphin Research Program c/o Mote Marine Laboratory Sarasota Florida USA
- Caroline R. Weir
- Falklands Conservation Stanley Falkland Islands
- Rebecca Wellard
- Centre for Marine Science and Technology Curtin University Bentley Western Australia Australia
- Randall Wells
- Chicago Zoological Society's Sarasota Dolphin Research Program c/o Mote Marine Laboratory Sarasota Florida USA
- Kymberly M. Yano
- NOAA Fisheries Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center Honolulu Hawai'i USA
- Jochen R. Zaeschmar
- Far Out Ocean Research Collective Paihia New Zealand
- Lars Bejder
- Marine Mammal Research Program, Hawai'i Institute of Marine Biology University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Kāne'ohe Hawai'i USA
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.14167
- Journal volume & issue
-
Vol. 14,
no. 10
pp. 2611 – 2625
Abstract
Abstract Researchers can investigate many aspects of animal ecology through noninvasive photo–identification. Photo–identification is becoming more efficient as matching individuals between photos is increasingly automated. However, the convolutional neural network models that have facilitated this change need many training images to generalize well. As a result, they have often been developed for individual species that meet this threshold. These single‐species methods might underperform, as they ignore potential similarities in identifying characteristics and the photo–identification process among species. In this paper, we introduce a multi‐species photo–identification model based on a state‐of‐the‐art method in human facial recognition, the ArcFace classification head. Our model uses two such heads to jointly classify species and identities, allowing species to share information and parameters within the network. As a demonstration, we trained this model with 50,796 images from 39 catalogues of 24 cetacean species, evaluating its predictive performance on 21,192 test images from the same catalogues. We further evaluated its predictive performance with two external catalogues entirely composed of identities that the model did not see during training. The model achieved a mean average precision (MAP) of 0.869 on the test set. Of these, 10 catalogues representing seven species achieved a MAP score over 0.95. For some species, there was notable variation in performance among catalogues, largely explained by variation in photo quality. Finally, the model appeared to generalize well, with the two external catalogues scoring similarly to their species' counterparts in the larger test set. From our cetacean application, we provide a list of recommendations for potential users of this model, focusing on those with cetacean photo–identification catalogues. For example, users with high quality images of animals identified by dorsal nicks and notches should expect near optimal performance. Users can expect decreasing performance for catalogues with higher proportions of indistinct individuals or poor quality photos. Finally, we note that this model is currently freely available as code in a GitHub repository and as a graphical user interface, with additional functionality for collaborative data management, via Happywhale.com.
Keywords