Genetic‐Guided Pharmacotherapy for Coronary Artery Disease: A Systematic and Critical Review of Economic Evaluations

Abstract

Background Genetic‐guided pharmacotherapy (PGx) is not recommended in clinical guidelines for coronary artery disease (CAD). We aimed to examine the extent and quality of evidence from economic evaluations of PGx in CAD and to identify variables influential in changing conclusions on cost‐effectiveness. Methods and Results From systematic searches across 6 databases, 2 independent reviewers screened, included, and rated the methodological quality of economic evaluations of PGx testing to guide pharmacotherapy for patients with CAD. Of 35 economic evaluations included, most were model‐based cost‐utility analyses alone, or alongside cost‐effectiveness analyses of PGx testing to stratify patients into antiplatelets (25/35), statins (2/35), pain killers (1/35), or angiotensin‐converting enzyme inhibitors (1/35) to predict CAD risk (8/35) or to determine the coumadin doses (1/35). To stratify patients into antiplatelets (96/151 comparisons with complete findings of PGx versus non‐PGx), PGx was more effective and more costly than non‐PGx clopidogrel (28/43) but less costly than non‐PGx prasugrel (10/15) and less costly and less effective than non‐PGx ticagrelor (22/25). To predict CAD risk (51/151 comparisons), PGx using genetic risk scores was more effective and less costly than clinical risk score (13/17) but more costly than no risk score (16/19) or no treatment (9/9). The remaining comparisons were too few to observe any trend. Mortality risk was the most common variable (47/294) changing conclusions. Conclusions Economic evaluations to date found PGx to stratify patients with CAD into antiplatelets or to predict CAD risk to be cost‐effective, but findings varied based on the non‐PGx comparators, underscoring the importance of considering local practice in deciding whether to adopt PGx.

Keywords

• cardiovascular disease
• coronary artery disease
• economic evaluation
• genetic testing
• pharmacogenetics
• systematic review