Resilience of Canola to <i>Plasmodiophora brassicae</i> (Clubroot) Pathotype 3H under Different Resistance Genes and Initial Inoculum Levels

Abstract

In this study, we explored the resilience of a clubroot resistance (CR) stacking model against a field population of Plasmodiophora brassicae pathotype 3H. This contrasts with our earlier work, where stacking CRaM and Crr1rutb proved only moderately resistant to pathotype X. Canola varieties carrying Rcr1/Crr1rutb and Rcr1 + Crr1rutb were repeatedly exposed to 3H at low (1 × 104/g soil) and high (1 × 107/g soil) initial resting spore concentrations over five planting cycles under controlled environments to mimic intensive canola production. Initially, all resistant varieties showed strong resistance. However, there was a gradual decline in resistance over time for varieties carrying only a single CR gene, particularly with Crr1rutb alone and at the high inoculum level, where the disease severity index (DSI) increased from 9% to 39% over five planting cycles. This suggests the presence of virulent pathotypes at initially low levels in the 3H inoculum. In contrast, the variety with stacked CR genes remained resilient, with DSI staying below 3% throughout, even at the high inoculum level. Furthermore, the use of resistant varieties, carrying either a single or stacked CR genes, reduced the total resting spore numbers in soil over time, while the inoculum level either increased or remained high in soils where susceptible Westar was continuously grown. Our study demonstrates greater resistance resilience for stacking Rcr1 and Crr1rutb against the field population of 3H. Additionally, the results suggest that resistance may persist even longer in fields with lower levels of inoculum, highlighting the value of extended crop rotation (reducing inoculum) alongside strategic CR-gene deployment to maximize resistance resilience.

Keywords

• <i>Brassica napus</i>
• canola
• resistance
• gene pyramiding
• <i>Plasmodiophora brassicae</i>
• pathotype