Physical Review Physics Education Research (May 2021)

Introductory physics lab instructors’ perspectives on measurement uncertainty

  • Benjamin Pollard,
  • Robert Hobbs,
  • Rachel Henderson,
  • Marcos D. Caballero,
  • H. J. Lewandowski

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010133
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 17, no. 1
p. 010133

Abstract

Read online Read online

Introductory physics lab courses serve as the starting point for students to learn and experience experimental physics at the undergraduate level. They often focus on measurement uncertainty, an essential topic for practicing physicists and a foundation for more advanced lab learning. As such, measurement uncertainty has been a focus when studying and improving introductory physics lab courses. There is a need for a research-based assessment explicitly focused on measurement uncertainty that captures the breadth of learning related to the topic, and that has been developed and documented in an evidence-centered way. In this work, we present the first step in the development of such an assessment, with the goal of establishing the breadth and depth of the domain of measurement uncertainty in introductory physics labs. We conducted and analyzed interviews with introductory physics lab instructors across the US, identifying prevalent concepts and practices related to measurement uncertainty, and their level of emphasis in introductory physics labs. We find that instructors discuss a range of measurement uncertainty topics beyond basic statistical ideas like mean and standard deviation, including those connected to modeling, another lab learning goal. We describe how these findings will be used in the subsequent development of the assessment, called the Survey Of Physics Reasoning On Uncertainty Concepts In Experiments (SPRUCE).