Attenuated but immunostimulatory Mycobacterium tuberculosis variant bovis strain Ravenel shows variation in T cell epitopes

Abstract

Abstract Tuberculosis, caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) organisms, affects a range of humans and animals globally. Mycobacterial pathogenesis involves manipulation of the host immune system, partially through antigen presentation. Epitope sequences across the MTBC are evolutionarily hyperconserved, suggesting their recognition is advantageous for the bacterium. Mycobacterium tuberculosis var. bovis (MBO) strain Ravenel is an isolate known to provoke a robust immune response in cattle, but typically fails to produce lesions and persist. Unlike attenuated MBO BCG strains that lack the critical RD1 genomic region, Ravenel is classic-type MBO structurally, suggesting genetic variation is responsible for defective pathogenesis. This work explores variation in epitope sequences in MBO Ravenel by whole genome sequencing, and contrasts such variation against a fully virulent clinical isolate, MBO strain 10-7428. Validated MTBC epitopes (n = 4818) from the Immune Epitope Database were compared to their sequences in MBO Ravenel and MBO 10-7428. Ravenel yielded 3 modified T cell epitopes, in genes rpfB, argC, and rpoA. These modifications were predicted to have little effect on protein stability. In contrast, T cells epitopes in 10-7428 were all WT. Considering T cell epitope hyperconservation across MTBC variants, these altered MBO Ravenel epitopes support their potential contribution to overall strain attenuation. The affected genes may provide clues on basic pathogenesis, and if so, be feasible targets for reverse vaccinology.