Unsupervised Detection of Covariate Shift Due to Changes in EEG Headset Position: Towards an Effective Out-of-Lab Use of Passive Brain–Computer Interface

Abstract

In the field of passive Brain–computer Interfaces (BCI), the need to develop systems that require rapid setup, suitable for use outside of laboratories is a fundamental challenge, especially now, that the market is flooded with novel EEG headsets with a good quality. However, the lack of control in operational conditions can compromise the performance of the machine learning model behind the BCI system. First, this study focuses on evaluating the performance loss of the BCI system, induced by a different positioning of the EEG headset (and of course sensors), so generating a variation in the control features used to calibrate the machine learning algorithm. This phenomenon is called covariate shift. Detecting covariate shift occurrences in advance allows for preventive measures, such as informing the user to adjust the position of the headset or applying specific corrections in new coming data. We used in this study an unsupervised Machine Learning model, the Isolation Forest, to detect covariate shift occurrence in new coming data. We tested the method on two different datasets, one in a controlled setting (9 participants), and the other in a more realistic setting (10 participants). In the controlled dataset, we simulated the movement of the EEG cap using different channel and reference configurations. For each test configuration, we selected a set of electrodes near the control electrodes. Regarding the realistic dataset, we aimed to simulate the use of the cap outside the laboratory, mimicking the removal and repositioning of the cap by a non-expert user. In both datasets, we recorded multiple test sessions for each configuration while executing a set of Workload tasks. The results obtained using the Isolation Forest model allowed the identification of covariate shift in the data, even with a 15-s recording sample. Moreover, the results showed a strong and significant negative correlation between the percentage of covariate shift detected by the method, and the accuracy of the passive BCI system (p-value < 0.01). This novel approach opens new perspectives for developing more robust and flexible BCI systems, with the potential to move these technologies towards out-of-the-lab use, without the need for supervision for use by a non-expert user.

Keywords

• passive brain–computer interface
• electroencephalography
• machine learning
• covariate shift