Journal of Deliberative Democracy (Jun 2022)

`Representing and Being Represented in Turn’ - A Symposium on Hélène Landemore’s "Open Democracy"

  • Christopher H. Achen,
  • Daniela Cammack,
  • Ethan J. Leib,
  • Hélène Landemore,
  • Jane Mansbridge,
  • Joshua Cohen,
  • Peter Stone

DOI
https://doi.org/10.16997/10.16997/jdd.1213
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 18, no. 1

Abstract

Read online Read online

Hélene Landemore’s Open Democracy challenges today’s democracies to meet their legitimacy deficits by opening up a wide array of participatory opportunities, from enhanced forms of direct democracy, to internet crowdsourcing, to representation through random selection to a citizens’ assembly: “representing and being represented in turn” (p. xvii).  Her aim: to replace citizen consent with citizen power.  The critics advance both praise and misgivings.  Joshua Cohen asks if Landemore's innovations are best understood as supplements or alternatives to the current system. Daniele Cammack argues for the significance of open mass meetings as well as smaller representative bodies. Peter Stone considers citizens’ assemblies inadequate for popular sovereignty.  Christopher Achen warns of problems in accurate representation, through both self-selection into the lottery and domination in the discussion. Ethan Lieb argues that particular innovations are useful only in some contexts, and that in each citizens should learn their appropriate role responsibilities. Landemore responds by agreeing, clarifying and rebutting.

Keywords