BMC Nursing (Aug 2024)
Effect of self-directed versus traditional learning model on nurses’ airway management competencies and patients’ airway-related incidents
Abstract
Abstract Introduction Self-directed learning (SDL) stands as a contemporary approach to learning, offering efficient and sustainable strategies for enhancing knowledge and practices. Given the pivotal role of nurses in ensuring patient safety and care effectiveness, this study aims to assess the impact of the SDL model compared to the traditional learning model (TLM) on elevating nurses’ airway management (AM) competencies and minimizing airway-related incidents. Methodology The study employed an experimental research design using a posttest-only control group structure within a two-group comparison framework. Seventy-two nurses participated, with 35 in the study group and 37 in the control group at the Obstetrics and Gynecology Hospital affiliated with Cairo University, Egypt. The trial was carried out between February 2020 and July 2021. Following an assessment of SDL readiness for the intervention group, they received SDL model training based on Knowles’ SDL principles, while the control group received TLM. The primary endpoint was a significant elevation in nurses’ airway management competency, with the secondary outcome being a significant decrease in airway-related incidents reported by nurses. Competency assessments occurred immediately after completion of the intervention and again three months later. Results A statistically significant difference was observed between the control and intervention groups regarding their practice and knowledge scores, with p-values of 0.02 and 0.05). Conclusion The SDL model significantly enhanced nurses’ competencies in AM compared to the TLM. However, the efficacy of both learning models diminishes over time. Although nurses who underwent SDL model reported fewer airway incidents compared to those who received TLM approach of learning, no statistically significant difference was detected. Trial registration The study has been registered with Clinical Trials.gov under the registration number (NCT04244565) on 28/01/2020.
Keywords
