Can New Ultrasound Signs Help in Identifying Follicular Variant of Papillary Carcinoma of Thyroid? – A Pilot Study

Abstract

Aim: To describe two new ultrasound signs for thyroid nodules – “nodule in nodule” and “hypoechoic internal septae” and assess their usefulness in differentiating follicular variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma (FVPTC) from benign thyroid nodules (BTN). Methodology: Ultrasound findings of 210 patients with histopathologically proven FVPTC (68 nodules, M:F=13:47 with mean age of 39.5±11.9 years) and BTN (165 nodules, (M:F=41:109 with mean age of 44±11.3 years) were retrospectively reviewed from PACS by a single radiologist blinded to the final diagnosis. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify the best predictors of FVPTC and their diagnostic performance was assessed. Results: The “nodule in nodule” sign was seen in 80.9% of FVPTC and only 12.1% of BTN. The “hypoechoic internal septae” sign was seen in 44.1% of FVPTC and 17% of BTN. Younger patients, heterogeneous echotexture, nodule in nodule sign, thick incomplete non-uniform halo and presence of significant nodes were the best predictors of FVPTC (p<0.05). The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, accuracy and relative risk for FVPTC given as odds ratio (95% CI) for heterogeneous echotexture and nodule in nodule sign which were the best 2 predictors of FVPTC were 91.2%, 81.8%, 67.3%, 95.7%, 84.5%, 46.5 (18.5–117.4) and 80.9%, 87.7%, 74.3%, 91.2%, 86.2%, 32.5 (15.04–70.2), respectively. There was improvement in the specificity (91.5%) and accuracy (86.6%) when a combined criterion of heterogeneous echotexture and nodule in nodule sign was applied to predict FVPTC. Conclusion: The “nodule in nodule” sign is common in FVPTC and when combined with heterogeneous echotexture can differentiate FVPTC and BTN with high specificity.

Keywords

• head/neck
• thyroid
• ultrasound