Journal for ImmunoTherapy of Cancer (May 2019)

The promise of Immuno-oncology: implications for defining the value of cancer treatment

  • Howard L. Kaufman,
  • Michael B. Atkins,
  • Prasun Subedi,
  • James Wu,
  • James Chambers,
  • T. Joseph Mattingly,
  • Jonathan D. Campbell,
  • Jeff Allen,
  • Andrea E. Ferris,
  • Richard L. Schilsky,
  • Daniel Danielson,
  • J. Leonard Lichtenfeld,
  • Linda House,
  • Wendy K. D. Selig

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40425-019-0594-0
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 7, no. 1
pp. 1 – 11

Abstract

Read online

Abstract The rapid development of immuno-oncology (I-O) therapies for multiple types of cancer has transformed the cancer treatment landscape and brightened the long-term outlook for many patients with advanced cancer. Responding to ongoing efforts to generate value assessments for novel therapies, multiple stakeholders have been considering the question of “What makes I-O transformative?” Evaluating the distinct features and attributes of these therapies, and better characterizing how patients experience them, will inform such assessments. This paper defines ways in which treatment with I-O is different from other therapies. It also proposes key aspects and attributes of I-O therapies that should be considered in any assessment of their value and seeks to address evidence gaps in existing value frameworks given the unique properties of patient outcomes with I-O therapy. The paper concludes with a “data needs catalogue” (DNC) predicated on the belief that multiple key, unique elements that are necessary to fully characterize the value of I-O therapies are not routinely or robustly measured in current clinical practice or reimbursement databases and are infrequently captured in existing research studies. A better characterization of the benefit of I-O treatment will allow a more thorough assessment of its benefits and provide a template for the design and prioritization of future clinical trials and a roadmap for healthcare insurers to optimize coverage for patients with cancers eligible for I-O therapy.

Keywords