Sensitivity and specificity of Nanopore sequencing for detecting carbapenem and 3rd-generation cephalosporin-resistant Enterobacteriaceae in urine samples: Real-time simulation with public antimicrobial resistance gene database

Abstract

Objectives: To evaluate the accuracy of beta-lactamase gene detection directly from urine samples by Nanopore sequencing. Methods: DNA was extracted from bacterial pellets in spun urine. The purified DNA was then sequenced in native form by a Nanopore sequencer (MinION) to identify the organisms and beta-lactamase genes. Results were compared to routine urine cultures and standard antimicrobial susceptibility tests (AST). Results: We processed 60 urine samples of which routine cultures grew Enterobacteriaceae, including 28 carbapenem-resistant (CRE), 17 extended-spectrum beta-lactamase (ESBL) or AmpC producing, and 15 non-ESBL/AmpC phenotypes. We excluded 7 samples with extremely low DNA amounts (<1 ng/μl) for a final case of 53 in total. The sensitivity of antimicrobial resistance gene detection within 6 h, the optimal duration from real-time simulation, of Nanopore sequencing for the diagnosis of carbapenem-resistant and ceftriaxone-resistant phenotypes was 73.9 % (95%CI 56.0–91.9 %) and 81.1 % (95%CI 68.5–93.7 %), while the specificity was 96.7 % (95%CI 90.2–100.0 %) and 56.3 % (95%CI 31.9–80.6 %), respectively. The median times for MinION to generate DNA reads containing carbapenemase and ESBL/AmpC genes were 93 min (IQR 17–245.5) and 99 min (IQR 31.25–269.75) after sequencing commencement, respectively. Conclusions: Nanopore sequencing can identify bacterial genotypic resistance in urine and may enable clinicians to adjust antimicrobial therapy earlier than routine AST.

Keywords

• Nanopore
• Carbapenemase
• ESBL
• AmpC
• Enterobacteriaceae